I listened to this last night. I've seen and heard things related to this story but I never actually read the original. This is narrated by Tom Mison, the star of the Sleepy Hollow tv show (which I love). His voice is perfect and I found myself picturing his character at times.
This was a bit funny and not very spooky, but I am glad I can finally check this off the list. It was fun to listen to, and I will be able to cover my "Pumpkin" square with this one. :)